June 30, 2006
At a time when South Australia announces a target of sourcing 20% of its energy from renewable sources by 2014 an editorial in The Australian denouces the whole approach to sustainable energy. It has a hysterical tone:
When federal Agriculture Minister Peter McGauran declared this week that wind farms are a "complete fraud" that "only exist on taxpayer subsidies", he injected the first dose of sanity seen in the renewable energy debate for a long time. Wind power fulfils just 2 per cent of the country's electricity needs, is unreliable even on the gustiest of days and is emblematic of everything wrong with the quest for so-called sustainability.
Huh? McGuaran made the remarks in an attempt to roll back the Liberals and raise the profile of the Nationals. Those remarks are just a launching pad:
It is not just on wind farms where politics and feelings are allowed to trump economic reality. Senator Campbell and his ilk like to be seen on the "right" side of the environment. Meanwhile, so-called progressives try to shut down debate over global warming even though the science is far from settled.....The Kyoto Protocol is far too flawed an instrument to reduce pollution. Australia needs to apply cost-benefit analyses to environmental issues, not sentiment or politics....Recycling plants dump toxic chemicals and salt into rivers – including the Murray.
No point in having recycling plants.Let's stay with dumping raw swerage into the Murray so Adelaide can drink it. So can be done?
It's simple.
Even in a world where carbon use is constrained, technologies such as clean coal and geosequestration make more sense for coal-rich Australia than wind power (or nuclear, for that matter). Feelgood environmentalism may win votes. But not only does it fail to pay the bills – it also doesn't save the planet.
So The Australian is speaking for the coal industry. II doesn't even consider research into solar power, not consider energy mixe.
|
The Lord on High Rupert is in town, so no wonder his lackey editor's go all out bashing one of HRH's favourite targets.
The Australian continues to decline, I see. I gave up reading it a couple of years ago, and don't miss it one bit.