Philosophical Conversations Public Opinion Junk for code
parliament house.gif
Think Tanks
Oz Blogs
Economic Blogs
Foreign Policy Blogs
International Blogs
Media Blogs
South Australian Weblogs
Economic Resources
Environment Links
Political Resources
South Australian Links
"...public opinion deserves to be respected as well as despised" G.W.F. Hegel, 'Philosophy of Right'

because.... « Previous | |Next »
December 17, 2012

It's the USA and there is no resolution in sight for gun control in spite of the recent violence in Newtown, Connecticut at the Sandy Hooke Elelmentary school. This was a massacre of 20 children and six adults on Friday, Dec. 14, by an intruder with an assault rifle (a Bushmaster .223). This is a semi-automatic version of the civilian model of the U.S. military M-16 manufactured by Colt.

Despite a history of mass shootings it's either gun rights or gun control for Americans. There are an estimated 280 million to 300 million guns in private hands in America—many legally owned, many not. Each year, more than 4 million new guns enter the market.


In District of Columbia v. Heller (2008) the US Supreme Court clearly held, for the first time, that the Second Amendment guarantees an individual’s right to possess a gun. That Amendment says:

A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.”

The present day gun-rights movement in the USA, which is predominantly white, rural, and politically conservative, interprets this to mean a right to own a hand weapon beyond the home to defend themselves against attackers with guns. They have to be prepared for the worst, they say.

Many of these gun owners are absolutists opposed to any government regulation of firearms and they argue that an increasingly armed public means a decreasing crime rate and that requiring background checks on buyers at gun shows represents a threat to the Constitution. Guns are a means to a less violent society. If the students and adults had guns then they would have been able to defend themselves. Schools and universities can turned into places for shootout.

The National Rifle Association's (NRA) little slogan is "guns don't kill people, people kill people." Many Americans are predisposed to agree with the basic message of the NRA that their right to bear arms is grounded in the Constitution, and they assume that gun violence is just the product of troubled or deranged individuals and not shaped by the economic and social context of places and class.

The cycle is a mass shooting, public outcry, political inaction, followed by the gun lobby 's victory in allowing lethal force to be used in more public places. In this culture of guns mourning the consequences of gun violence is acceptable but discussing how to prevent more tragedies is not.

| Posted by Gary Sauer-Thompson at 6:51 AM | | Comments (10)


Sadly, it's another element in the mindless partisan ideological war in the USA. Gun control is perceived as part of the 'Leftist agenda', therefore must be attacked and reviled by every right-thinking conservative. As with climate change and foreign policy and so many other issues, evidence-based discussion gave way to strident dogma long ago.

Can a black, socialist, unpatriotic, close-Muslim president dampen America's gun-lust. Not damn likely...

The gun lobby argues that the gun-free zones in schools are "a magnet for deranged killers," and the solution is to arm the teachers.

Yeah, give them semi-automatics, or even assault weapons, that are designed to be self-loading. Arm the teachers to their teeth. Get them to wear riot gear and drive to school in armoured vehicles. Turn the school into an armed camp.

The gun lobby thinks that contemporary America is like the wild west before the towns had sheriffs.

Is the Shooters and Fishers party in NSW similar to the NRA in the USA ?

The Americans seem to think that it is the government that is the problem and that heh government should get out of ghe way.

"The gun lobby thinks that contemporary America is like the wild west before the towns had sheriffs. "

Toddlers should armed against their parents. The bad guys are everywhere. Everyone knows that.

Its a bit like collateral damage i spose.

Mike Huckabee blamed the mass violence on the removal of God from schools.

The conservatives have got their story straight now. Gun violence is all the fault of Leftists, who apparently insisted years ago as part of their perverted ideology that mentally disturbed people not be institutionalised, but allowed to wander around slaughtering innocent schoolkids. Ah those damn liberals, there is nothing they can't be blamed for.

The only thing missing is the explanation of how the Leftists managed to do this evil over the resistance of right-thinking True Americans but no doubt Acorn and voter fraud were involved somehow.

Obama is mystifying at best, but seems a typical Blairite; big on talk but no action.