Thought-Factory.net Philosophical Conversations Public Opinion philosophy.com Junk for code

Mandy Martin, Puritjarra 2, 2005. For further information on MANDY MARTIN, refer here: http://www.mandy-martin.com/
If there are diverse kinds of knowledge and ways of knowing place, then we need to learn to value the different ways each of us sees a single place that is significant, but differently so, for each perspective.
RECENT ENTRIES
SEARCH
ARCHIVES
Library
Thinkers/Critics/etc
WEBLOGS
Australian Weblogs
Critical commentary
Visual blogs
CULTURE
ART
PHOTOGRAPHY
DESIGN/STREET ART
ARCHITECTURE/CITY
Film
MUSIC
Sexuality
FOOD & WiNE
Other
www.thought-factory.net
looking for something firm in a world of chaotic flux

a salutory tale « Previous | |Next »
February 7, 2005

Remember all the fuss about the rebuilding of World Trade Centre after 9/11? Remember the THINK design, which showed a pair of airy latticework cylinders arising over the twin towers' footprints and incorporated various components of a World Cultural Center? The one where commercial development would have been pushed to the periphery of the site. Remember the winning design by Daniel Liebskind?

Have a quick look here. Well the New York Review of Books has a tale to tell. It was accurately foretold by Ada Louise Huxtable:

[New York is] "a city incapable of the large, appropriate gesture in the public interest if it costs too much....If the usual scenario is followed, the debate will lead to a "solution" in which principle is lost and an epic opportunity squandered. With the best intentions the Municipal Art Society, a conscientious watchdog of the city's urban quality, will announce a competition to determine what should be done with the site. The results will make a nice little exhibition, and discussions and lectures will be held. All this will be ignored by the movers and shakers making big building plans under the banner of physical and symbolic reconstruction. There will be a fuss in the press, with letters to the editor, pro and con. City Hall, in a split political decision between greed and glory, will come out for the builders and a memorial---a monument or a small park, something financially inoffensive in the larger scheme of things."

The usual scenario has been followed. Commerce wins. Libeskind was quickly sidelined and replaced by David Childs the developer's (Larry Silverstein) architect. The developer calls the shots and he wanted a developer office building.

| Posted by Gary Sauer-Thompson at 1:29 AM | | Comments (0)
Comments