Thought-Factory.net Philosophical Conversations Public Opinion philosophy.com Junk for code

Mandy Martin, Puritjarra 2, 2005. For further information on MANDY MARTIN, refer here: http://www.mandy-martin.com/
If there are diverse kinds of knowledge and ways of knowing place, then we need to learn to value the different ways each of us sees a single place that is significant, but differently so, for each perspective.
RECENT ENTRIES
SEARCH
ARCHIVES
Library
Thinkers/Critics/etc
WEBLOGS
Australian Weblogs
Critical commentary
Visual blogs
CULTURE
ART
PHOTOGRAPHY
DESIGN/STREET ART
ARCHITECTURE/CITY
Film
MUSIC
Sexuality
FOOD & WiNE
Other
www.thought-factory.net
looking for something firm in a world of chaotic flux

River Murray wake « Previous | |Next »
July 18, 2009

A wake was held at Clayton last weekend marking the death of the River Murray. It was held by the River, Lakes and Coorong Action Group (RLCAG) to protest against the building of the temporary flow regulator (a weir) between Hindmarsh Island and Clayton Bay and two others to raise water levels, limiting the exposure of acid sulphate soils to the air.

09June07_Port Adelaide _224.jpg Gary Sauer-Thompson, abandoned cottage, Point Malcolm,Lake Alexandrina, 2009

The Clayton Bay weir will have the effect of cutting Lake Alexandrina off from the fresh water flows of the Finness River and Currency Creek. The implication is that parts of the Murray river in South Australia which are dying are being let go to ensure the survival of other parts. The crisis in this region is one where we're now in a situation where the Lower Lakes have been emptied out.

In fact everything has been emptied out. There's nowhere else to go, there's no reserves in the system. If the drought continues, there will almost certainly not be adequate fresh water available to maintain the previous state of the Lakes.

If you don’t let the freshwater down to avoid acidification in the lower lakes, then it’s pretty much inevitable that they’ll have to let the saltwater in. We are prepared to use water to keep crops alive that need to be kept alive, if people are to make a living, and plant new crops, but we are not prepared to spend them on buying water to keep the ecology of the Lower Lakes and the Coorong alive. Labor Governments across the country are prepared to sit back and let the Coorong and lower Lakes die to protect their irrigators.

I'm planning a little trip to Broken Hill next week and I'm going to explore what's been happening in the Darling River and the Menindee Lakes in NSW. I suspect that the Menindee Lakes will be dry and the Darling River a series of pools.

The wake should have happened several years ago when the River Murray stopped flowing to the sea a few years. it was then that the fresh water stopped flowing into the Coorong, and then the river mouth closed up completely, so the salt water couldn't get in either, and the Coorong started to dry up. For several years now, there have been dredges at the Murray Mouth, fighting to keep it open, but they can't seem to keep it wide enought or deep enough for a satisfactory amount of water to enter the Coorong. What salt water makes it into the Coorong Channel (the bit between the Murray Mouth and the Coorong proper) cannot make it all the way into the Coorong before the tide turns, and it all flushes out again.

| Posted by Gary Sauer-Thompson at 3:47 PM | | Comments (5)
Comments

Comments

As the Save the Lakes group say:

the problem of the lack of water in the Lower Lakes can and should be decoupled from the rest of the problems of the Murray-Darling Basin by virtue of the Lower Lakes' proximity to the sea. By opening the barrages to let in seawater, the Lower Lakes can be reconstructed and returned to a natural tidal estuary. This will conserve fresh water and maximize environmental flows for damaged wetlands up river that do not have the option of the sea.

They also advocate construction of a weir near Wellington in order to conserve freshwater in the River Murray and protect South Australia's water supply from contamination and the construction of embankments on the Currency and Finniss creeks to conserve freshwater from local rainfalls and preserve these wetlands as local freshwater havens.

Sue,
In contrast, the River, Lakes and Coorong Action Group (RLCAG) appear to be opposed to the weir at Wellington and the Clayton regulator. They say that the water from the Finness and Currency Creek and Tookayerta Creek should flow into Lake Alexandrina. They are holding a peaceful vigil at the Fresh Water Embassy.

'No weir ' is the core message because they see the lower lakes region as the Rann government’s ‘Sacrificial Lamb’ that will have a significant negative impact on business, community and consumer confidence. Secondly, it will sever the Murray-Darling Basin estuary (the Ramsar listed, internationally significant wetlands of the Lower Murray Lakes and Coorong) from the rest of the river system, starving it of fresh water.

What do the River, Lakes and Coorong Action Group (RLCAG) say about where the water is going to come from to keep the lakes covered? There is no water in reserve.

The Wilderness Society says that the only way to restore the Murray River system to health is for the Government to buy back water from the irrigation industry and return it to the river.

The proposed temporary weir at Wellington is designed to help maintain a pumping pool and ensure that water can still be supplied to Adelaide for drinking water.

The Menindee Lakes is a seen as storage with high levels of ‘dead storage’. This is water which is not able to be returned to the Darling river it was diverted from without the use of pumps. The Menindee Lakes are so hydrologically inefficient it is hard to be specific what its dead storage figure is – suffice to say that it is well over 300 GL. If this storage were reconfigured it could guarantee extra GL annually for the Lower Lakes.

Despite an EIS having being undertaken and significant COAG funding being available, reconfiguration work at the Menindee Lakes is still yet to proceed.