Thought-Factory.net Philosophical Conversations Public Opinion philosophy.com Junk for code

Mandy Martin, Puritjarra 2, 2005. For further information on MANDY MARTIN, refer here: http://www.mandy-martin.com/
If there are diverse kinds of knowledge and ways of knowing place, then we need to learn to value the different ways each of us sees a single place that is significant, but differently so, for each perspective.
RECENT ENTRIES
SEARCH
ARCHIVES
Library
Thinkers/Critics/etc
WEBLOGS
Australian Weblogs
Critical commentary
Visual blogs
CULTURE
ART
PHOTOGRAPHY
DESIGN/STREET ART
ARCHITECTURE/CITY
Film
MUSIC
Sexuality
FOOD & WiNE
Other
www.thought-factory.net
looking for something firm in a world of chaotic flux

Victor Harbor: foreshore erosion « Previous | |Next »
September 11, 2009

Whilst walking the dogs on the beach at Encounter Bay at Victor Harbor in the mornings and evenings this week, I've been noticing the effect of the tide on the foreshore compared to the past. The erosion of the sand dunes has been quite marked from the storm surges this winter:

Encounter Bay, erosin_.jpg Gary Sauer-Thompson, erosion, Encounter Bay, Victor Harbor, 2009

I imagine that this is how the rising sea levels caused by global heating manifests itself--as a steady erosion of the sand dunes from the higher tides and the wilder weather. This erosion will continue due to warming of the oceans and the consequent thermal expansion and melting of non-polar glaciers and icecaps and the ice sheets of Antarctica and Greenland. Seawater will forced its way through sand dunes and spilled across the low-lying land

The Victor Harbor City Council will be required to protect the coastal area rather than retreat since abandonment is not usually an option. Part of adapting to rising sea levels will, presumably, involve building protective sea walls for the resort-area beaches:

Encounter Bay, erosion#3_.jpg Gary Sauer-Thompson, erosion + Maleleuca, Encounter Bay, Victor Harbor, 2009

Many would argue that this erosion is not unusual in that beach and sand dunes built-up during months of relative calm will be eroded during stormy seasons, only to be built-up again after the storms have passed. As well, wave action and currents are continually moving sand along the shore, often resulting in a net drift of material in one direction.

However, the storm surges and beach erosion must be more severe than usual because the City Council has placed several lines (groynes?) of sand bags from the dunes to the sea in order to protect the dunes from tidal movement. Secondly, that ignores that sea levels along the South Australian coast are expected to rise by up to 40 cm above 1990 levels by 2050 and by 90 cm by 2100, with each one centimeter of rise resulting in one meter of erosion on low-lying beaches.

That means the coastline will move inward. What is now currently a vegetated dune will become the beach. There is not that much distance (or height) from the outer edge of the sand dunes to the foreshore holiday houses along the coastline near the city. So far the Council's response to beaches shrinking as the sand is washed away is sand deposits in order to protect the beaches.

| Posted by Gary Sauer-Thompson at 2:06 PM | | Comments (4)
Comments

Comments

See the National Seachange Taskforce --a national body that represents the interests of coastal councils and communities experiencing the effects of rapid population and tourism growth. They now realize that coastal areas are exposed to particular risks associated with climate change and that climate change is a critical issue for coastal communities and councils.

The Victor Harbor City Council's urban Growth Management Strategy only mentions climate change in passing. On page 81 it says:

3.6.1.1 Issues
Planning for adaptation to climate change is a relatively new concept. South Australia has been the first State to legislate targets to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, with legal targets for emission cuts and mandatory renewal targets under the Climate Change and Greenhouse Emissions Reduction Act 2007. “Tackling Climate Change: South Australia’s Greenhouse Strategy 2007 – 2020” includes an Action Plan for State Government Agencies to implement, up to 2012.

Examples of some projected regional impacts of climate change include:
• Increased frequency of higher temperatures –increasing energy consumption in warmer months;
• Sea level rise combined with more intense and regular storms – increasing the vulnerability of low lying coasts with limited setback to adapt. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change projects a 9cm to 88cm sea level rise by 2100;
• More extreme rainfall events – increasing flooding potential in low lying areas.
• By 2020, significant loss of biodiversity in some ecologically rich sites, including the Great Barrier Reef and Queensland Wet Tropics;
• By 2030, water security problems are projected to intensify in southern and eastern Australia;
• By 2030, production from agriculture and forestry is projected to decline over much of southern and eastern Australia due to increased drought and fire.

3.6.1.2 Opportunities
The adoption of climate change science in future planning for Victor Harbor would:
• support opportunities for energy efficient urban design, water sensitive design andsustainable energy generation;
• constrain capital intensive development in low-lying areas susceptible to sea level rise along the coast or susceptible to increased flooding risk adjacent watercourses;
• support opportunities for more capital intensive,higher density development on elevated land further from the coast.

There's nothing about which low coastal areas are vulnerable and have with limited setback to adapt. It would be the area from the Bluff to the city.

The real cost of increased erosion, storms and sea-level rises exacerbated by global warming have yet to be faced.

This presents local people and the local government with a stark dilemma. Is it worth spending billions on defending homes and livelihoods? Or, faced with inexorable sea-level rise, should expensive coastal defences be abandoned, leading to the evacuation of land and houses?

Yep the low lying wetlands will definitely salinate from rising sea levels, especially around the Murray Mouth and Lake Alexandrina. The Goolwa barrages can now be seen as sea defences. Land will increasingly be abandoned to the sea and the sea will form new salt marshes behind it.

There is a debate in the lower lakes region but it is mostly about preserving the unique freshwater habitat with increased inflows from the River Murray. Rising sea levels is not much of a consideration at the moment. Have the local councils put their head in the sand and say nothing is happening?I have heard no mention of the use of Dutch sea defences - a slow, gradual slope - rather than the wall-style defences.