|
August 6, 2010
In his 'Art, Common Sense and Photography' essay Victor Burgin says that because we have separate words for 'form' and 'content' we are mislead into believing that they stand for totally distinct areas of experience. He adds that there is no content without form and no form without content.
This argued against those modernist photographers who claimed that they could present a totally content-free world of pure forms and those left activists (social documentary photographers) who claim that the autonomous power of the truth can be stated regardless of formal considerations.
To ease his way out of this either or that framed our understanding of photography in the 1970s, Burgin turns to semiotics or semiology and argues that the photograph is a complex of signs used to communicate a message.
He says:
If you show me a photograph of a pile stones then, at an intermediate level, my eye receives visual noise just as my ear received verbal noise when you spoke to me in Greek, We can suppose that I have seen photographs since I was in a child and so have no problem interpreting these irregular patches of light and dark tones as representing stones. But beyond this? If I go on to remark that the photography depicts a temple, that the temple is ruined, and that it is Greek, then I relying on knowledge that that is no longer 'natural' , 'purely visual'; I am relying on knowledge that is cultural, verbally transmitted and, in the final analysis, ideological (I might think 'cradle of civilization', or damned Greek' according to when and where I happened to be born.
All photographers are aware of using some kind of effects in their work. They assume that the effect is to be achieved with the formal --the visual---since content is assumed to be just there in the world and therefore in the picture. But once we reject the idea of photography as a purely visual language understood by everybody, then we may consider the possibility that content too, may be produced as deliberately as one may plan the formal composition of the photograph.
|